Finned Fish
An almost-complete Fish with one or more fins in the same box. It allows a precise candidate elimination inside that box.
What it is
A Finned Fish uses the candidates for one digit. Two base rows and two cover columns form a Finned X-Wing; three lines form a Finned Swordfish. Rows and columns can swap roles. All candidates on the base lines lie in the cover lines, except for one or more fins on exactly one base line. All fins and at least one base position on that line must share a 3×3 box. There are two cases: if a fin is true, it excludes the digit elsewhere in its box. If every fin is false, a regular Fish remains, so the digit in the base lines occupies the cover lines. Both cases exclude the digit in the fin box on the cover line through the matching base position, but only outside the base lines. This proves a candidate elimination, not a placement.
How to spot it
Choose one digit and check all its current candidate positions on two or three base lines of the same orientation. The base positions must fit in the same number of cover lines, with at least two base positions on each base line. Only one base line may have extra candidates outside the cover lines. All these fins must share one box with a base position on that same line. Look for targets on its cover line inside that box, but outside every base line. Do not remove a base candidate or extend the elimination outside the fin box. Fins in another box do not meet these conditions.
Worked example
Check 5 in rows 6 and 7: the fin at r6c5, its box and the target at r5c6.
Step 1 of 4: Follow the 5
Focus on 5. The next steps show its possible places and the extra fin. The larger digits are givens and do not change.
Show additional details
The digits 6, 3, 8, 4, 1 are already placed in row 6.
The digit 5 can go only in , , within row 6.
The digits 7, 4, 6, 8 are already placed in row 7.
The digit 5 can go only in , within row 7.
The digits 8, 2, 9, 3 are already placed in column 6.
The digit 5 can go only in , , within column 6.
The digits 4 are already placed in column 9.
The digit 5 can go only in , , , , within column 9.
The digits 9 are already placed in box 5.
The digit 5 can go only in , , , , within box 5.
The remaining candidates for are 2, 5, 7.
The remaining candidates for are 5, 7.
The remaining candidates for are 2, 5, 7, 9.
The remaining candidates for are 1, 5.
The remaining candidates for are 1, 2, 3, 5, 9.
The marked 2-line Fish has an extra fin candidate inside the same box. (box 5): .
Why it matters
Finned Fish is useful because real expert grids rarely present a perfect rectangle. The extra candidate looks like a flaw, but the box constraint restores a precise local conclusion. It is the bridge between regular Fish and more flexible chain reasoning.
Practise now
Recognise and apply the technique in a matching practice position.
Frequently asked questions
How is Finned Fish different from X-Wing?
An X-Wing has no extra candidate on its two base lines. A Finned Fish has one or more fins outside the base cross-lines. The extra candidate prevents a whole-line elimination, but the shared box still permits a smaller, local elimination.
Where can I remove the candidate?
Only in the fin box, on the cross-line through the matching Fish corner, and outside the Fish base lines. Removing the digit anywhere else would overstate the proof.
Can a Finned Fish use three lines?
Yes. Sudoku Luna verifies Finned X-Wing and Finned Swordfish patterns. The larger pattern follows the same rule: all base cross-lines must fit, and the fin box must justify the exact target cells.
Put it to use
Where you will meet it
Use your candidate notes to look for this pattern in an Expert grid. Its availability depends on the position, not only the difficulty label.
Play ExpertStuck on a grid of your own?
Enter the position in the solver. It explains the safe steps it finds with supported techniques and stops if it cannot prove further progress. It may not use this particular technique.
Open the solverPrefer paper? Ready-made Expert sets as a PDF.Print puzzles
Finished reading? Mark it done and the learning path remembers where you got to.