Innies and outies
Innies lie inside and outies outside a chosen row, column or box. Compare the relevant cage sums with 45 to find their total.
What it is
Every complete row, column and box contains the digits 1 to 9 and totals 45. For innies, add all cages wholly inside the chosen unit: 45 minus that sum is the total of the remaining inside cells. For outies, add every cage touching the unit exactly once: that sum minus 45 is the total of their outside cells. What matters is complete coverage of the unit, not whether an individual cage lies mostly inside or outside.
How to spot it
Choose a row, column or box and inspect its cage boundaries. If the wholly contained cages leave exactly one unsolved inside cell, you can find an innie. If all touching cages cover the unit plus exactly one unsolved outside cell, you can find an outie. With several unsolved boundary cells, you initially know only their combined sum.
Worked example
Step through the example: first the position, then the cages and units supporting the argument, then the relevant candidates, and finally the conclusion.
Step 1 of 4: Look at the top-left box. All cages touching it cover its nine cells and exactly one outside cell: r3c4.
- Pattern cells
- 1/1, 1/2, 1/3, 2/1, 2/2, 2/3, 3/1, 3/2, 3/3, 3/4
- Digits
- 2
- Follows from it
- 3/4
Press a marked square to point it out on the board above.
Why it matters
Innies and outies help when cage boundaries cross a row, column or box. Comparing the cage totals with the region total can reveal a missing digit without solving each cage first. Start with one unknown inside or outside cell; several unknowns need further reasoning.
Practise now
Each practice board has one outside cell of a box that can be determined with innies and outies. Select the touching cages and check their combined sum before opening the proof.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an innie and an outie?
An innie is an inside cell not covered by the cages wholly contained in the unit. An outie is an outside cell belonging to a cage that touches the unit. The chosen unit and the cells covered by the counted cages determine the deduction.
When is the deduction strongest?
When the relevant sum calculation leaves exactly one unsolved inside or outside cell after subtracting known boundary digits, you can place the calculated digit there. With several unsolved cells, you know only their combined sum, not each cell’s digit.
Can I combine several units?
Yes, for disjoint units: two distinct boxes total 90, and three distinct rows total 135. Do not simply count a row and an intersecting box as 90, because their shared cells would be counted twice. The linked lesson “Rule of 45 across several units” below explains the extension.
Put it to use
Where you will meet it
Use your candidate notes to look for this pattern in a hard grid. The linked exercise offers a matching practice position.
Play HardStuck on a grid of your own?
Enter the position in the solver. It explains the safe steps it finds with supported techniques and stops if it cannot prove further progress. It may not use this particular technique.
Open the solverFinished reading? Mark it done and the learning path remembers where you got to.